My Login
By The Printing for Less Team
When Printing for Less’s National Account Executive, James Casey, and Director of Merchandising and Creative Services, Amber Sikkink, convened to walk marketers through direct mail optimization, the conversation quickly moved past the usual talking points to this: the “20 percent that lives in creative execution.”
During a recent virtual event hosted by the company—”From Bad to Best: Fixing Direct Mail That Doesn’t Perform”—the pair pulled back the curtain on how businesses of every size can transform their direct mail from generic, forgettable pieces into high-performing campaigns. The result was an example-driven session that challenged quite a few assumptions.
The 40/40/20 Rule: Where Creative Lives
Most direct mail practitioners know the “40/40/20” rule, but few apply it with discipline. Explained Sikkink:
- 40 percent of a campaign’s overall performance comes down to audience
- Another 40 percent lies in the offer itself
- The final 20 percent belongs to creative—design, format, and copy.
“You’ve decided someone’s worth getting your message. You’ve decided you’re going to give them something,” Sikkink explained. “How are you going to push them over the edge to take that next step?” The answer? When you’re targeting and your offer is solid, creative becomes the deciding factor between a piece that converts and one that doesn’t.
Where Direct Mail Can Fail
Casey and Sikkink first addressed the most common failure modes—the reasons direct mail underperforms when the audience and offer are strong:
- Weak or unclear headlines that fail to communicate value at the first glance.
- Poor visual hierarchy that leaves the reader without a clear path through the piece.
- Too much text, creating visual clutter that readers simply skip.
- The wrong format for the message—not every offer suits every mail format.
- A compelling offer that doesn’t immediately jump out and get attention.
- No trackable call to action, making it impossible to measure ROI.
This example postcard highlights creative elements that work and those that fail.
“Someone is going to decide whether they will continue reading a piece or set it aside within two to three seconds,” Sikkink noted. “You’ve got to have a compelling headline that draws them in, and it’s got to be relevant.”
Good, Better, Best: Learning from Real Examples
Using the plumbing company pictured, Sikkink and Casey showed how the progression from a basic postcard to a professionally designed piece could move the needle.
The weakest example led with a vague headline: “We are here when you need us,” paired with a generic image and a wall of text on the back. As stated, the business was a plumber, but you could barely grasp that from the front of the card. And the call to action (CTA) was buried.
“It’s a lot of copy and there’s no real hierarchy,” Sikkink said. “Nothing jumps out.”
The improved version made one significant leap with a prominent, bold: “$50 off any emergency service.” A stronger hierarchy on the back broke the content into more digestible chunks using whitespace, and the phone number stood out. But it still lacked a QR code, and the image didn’t quite match the service.
The best version (see below)—redesigned by the Printing for Less in-house graphics team—brought everything together. A cohesive red-and-blue color scheme matched industry expectations. The offer appeared at the top with an expiration date and a unique coupon code. A QR code with a clear arrow and the instruction “SCHEDULE HERE” removed all ambiguity. The back of the card used hierarchy, icons, and selective bolding to guide the eye naturally.
Postcard highlighted to show how key elements draw and hold attention.
Postcards vs. Letters: Right Format, Right Effect
One of the session’s more nuanced sections dealt with format selection—a decision that carries more strategic weight than most marketers give it credit for.
Postcards, Casey explained, are best understood as billboards in the mailbox. They’re efficient, fast to produce, and ideal for short sales cycles, simple offers, and brand awareness. The cardinal rule: headlines of seven words or less.
“Think about how you’re going to stand out,” Sikkink agreed. “If the message can’t be communicated at a glance, a postcard might not be the right vehicle.”
Letters, on the other hand, carry a perceived value that postcards cannot replicate. The physical act of opening an envelope increases engagement. For B2B outreach, account-based marketing, and executive-level campaigns where the goal is to make someone feel personally addressed, a letter works.
“People know that a letter is a higher-value piece to send than a postcard,” Casey noted. For anything requiring HIPAA compliance, sensitive personalized information, or a return envelope for contributions, letters are the natural choice.
Variable Data: Personalization Beyond First Names
The session placed emphasis on variable data processing—the ability to customize mail pieces based on individual recipient data—as one of the most powerful tools available. Sikkink was quick to challenge the notion that personalization stops at inserting a first name.
“Whatever information you have on a customer, you can incorporate within the letter. For prospects at the top of the funnel, a name and address could be all that’s available. Further down, however, purchase history, service preferences, or life events can all shape your message.”
The practical payoff is significant. Printing for Less’s team builds variable data templates that map directly to a customer’s data fields, enabling one piece of artwork to generate hundreds of tailored versions.
Casey added that once a variable data setup is configured, it becomes an asset with a long shelf life. Seasonal creative swaps—a spring offer replacing a winter one, for instance—can refresh the campaign without rebuilding.
Tracking: Making Each Campaign Accountable
Unique coupon codes are among the most effective tools.
“A simple suffix convention—”PC” for postcard, “E” for email—makes attribution simple,” Explained Sikkink. QR codes can link to unique landing pages, feed directly into Google Analytics, or trigger automated follow-up sequences in marketing platforms such as Salesforce, Marketo, or Eloqua.
She also recommended pairing QR codes with the associated web address printed nearby—giving tech-hesitant recipients the option to type the URL instead. Other practical tracking mechanisms include personalized URLs (PURLs), unique phone numbers per channel, and physical card turn-ins.
“Just make sure you’re capturing the data,” Amber urged.
The Multi-Touch Mindset
One of the session’s most actionable takeaways was the argument against single-send campaigns. Sikkink drew on basic consumer psychology: one mailer creates mild interest; a second reinforces it and drives action.
“Put yourself in the recipient’s standpoint,” she said. “If you get one offer, you’re kind of like, ‘Oh, maybe.’ But if you get a second, it starts to push you over the edge.”
Takeaway for Direct Mail Marketers
For businesses wondering whether direct mail still earns its place in a digital-first marketing mix, the answer from Printing for Less’s practitioners is unambiguous: When the creative is right, the targeting is precise, and the offer is compelling, the mailbox remains one of the most powerful channels available.
